Microfinance – does it work?

As the world struggles to find a ‘new normal’ for our financial systems, we take a look at an approach that has had some success, as well as some controversy.

‘Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach a man how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.’ So goes the well-known proverb, but it is also the principal behind microfinance: Give a person a cash hand-out and they’ll have money for a limited time, give them a microfinance programme and they will become financially sustainable. Ok, so it’s not quite so catchy, but this financial approach has been hailed as a way to help people rise out of poverty.

But what does it involve and does it really work?

What is microfinance?

Microfinance aims to bring banking services to people that would otherwise have no access. This might be the unemployed or low-income groups, and is often focused on those living in poverty in developing countries such as India and across Africa. Globally, 1.7 billion people have little or no access to formal financial services that can help them increase their incomes and change their lives1.

Microfinance includes microcredit or microloans – sometimes as little as £100 – but it offers more too. People can access other financial services, for example insurance, savings accounts and financial or business training. This is ideally provided by organisations on a not-for-profit basis, with the aim of enabling economic self-sufficiency2. The benefits can reach out beyond the individual; a microenterprise started with microfinance can, in time, employ others and lead to a dynamic SME culture.

The concept of modern microfinance really began in 1974, when an economics lecturer called Muhammad Yunus at the University of Chittagong, in Bangladesh, decided to lend $27 to some villagers living in poverty. They paid him back, and a new model, of ethical and empowering finance was born, resulting in Yunus eventually being awarded the Nobel peace prize3.

How is microfinance accessed?

Microfinance began with non-profit organisations, but over time, the number of profit-seeking microfinance institutions (MFIs) has increased. Investopedia lists some of the largest and most influential MFIs4 as:

  • 51Give – a non-profit organisation, collecting charitable donations and providing an e-commerce platform for other MFIs. As of 2020, they were being used by more than 100 charities.
  • Bank Raykat Indonesia – 70% government owned, it provides small scale finance through thousands of branches throughout southeast Asia, on a for profit basis.
  • Grameen Bank – the original MFI, linked back to ‘father of microfinance’ Muhammad Yunus. It has been for profit since 1983.

When microfinance turns bad

There is nothing fundamentally wrong with for profit organisations in the microfinance sector; it can result in more funds available for people to access if ethics remain at the heart. However, where there is cash, there is often corruption and some have sought to profit from this model of finance without an ethical approach, which has been to the detriment of those living in poverty.

As microfinance grew in popularity, reports began emerging of problematic practices. Where the demand for microfinance was high, checks were not carried out about a borrower’s assets and minimal support was offered to ensure that money was being put to productive use5.

More alarmingly, suicide rates soared amongst those who had accessed microloans. In 2010, more than 200 borrowers in the state of Andhra Pradesh, India, killed themselves. It is claimed that borrowers were verbally harassed, forced to pawn valuable items and publicly shamed. Allegedly, some were forced to drink battery acid if they were unable to pay back their loan. An independent investigation implicated market leader, SKS Microfinance, in seven of the deaths6.

There was also criticism of the high interest rates associated with loans – defended by providers because the transaction cost is high relative to the amount of money borrowed7. The positive buzz around microfinance was cut short, and it was claimed that banks were making excessive profits.

Regulation

The industry responded with self-regulatory measures to improve the sector, leading to a Barometer of Microfinance aiming to analyse the impact of investments. Microfinance has continued to grow: In 2018, there were 139.9 million borrowers, up from 98 million in 2009. Of these 139.9 million borrowers, 80% were women and 65% were rurally-based8.

Just as in the charitable sector, the opportunity for damaging practice and dangerous mismanagement is inherent in a system that involves working with the most vulnerable individuals in society, but should this cloud our judgement of the merits of microfinance?

Can microfinance make a real difference?

Overall, the concept behind microfinance is attractive; empower and enable people to rise out of poverty. In practice, the opportunity for corruption exists. If avoided, does ethical microfinance really help?

A successful business depends not only on a cash injection and some sense of a business plan, but also on good health (reliant on sanitation, medical provision, food and clean water), basic education (numeracy and literacy), infrastructure such as roads, a reliable transport network and marketing support.

As Sam Daley-Harris, Director of the Microcredit Summit Campaign, explained, “Microfinance is not the solution to global poverty, but neither is health, or education, or economic growth. There is no one single solution to global poverty. The solution must include a broad array of empowering interventions. Microfinance, when targeted to the very poor and effectively run, is one powerful tool.”9

It is also interesting to note that because it is an optional programme, it is most likely to be taken up by those who are already entrepreneurial by nature, leaving the more cautious behind.

When delivered ethically, with adequate regulation and as part of a wider strategy, microfinance can provide exciting opportunities. Yet on its own, microfinance is not a golden bullet for poverty reduction.


1 https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/financialinclusion/overview

2 https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/microfinance.asp

3 https://www.theguardian.com/katine/2008/jun/03/livelihoods.projectgoals1

4 https://www.investopedia.com/articles/insurance/090116/5-biggest-microfinance-companies-bbrijk.asp

5 https://www.businessinsider.com/hundreds-of-suicides-in-india-linked-to-microfinance-organizations-2012-2?r=US&IR=T

6 https://www.businessinsider.com/hundreds-of-suicides-in-india-linked-to-microfinance-organizations-2012-2?r=US&IR=T

7 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23311975.2018.1540072?src=recsys&

8 http://www.convergences.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Microfinance-Barometer-2019_web-1.pdf

9 https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6301036.pdf


Content of the articles featured in this publication is for your general information and use only and is not intended to address your particular requirements. They should not be relied upon in their entirety and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute, advice. Although endeavours have been made to provide accurate and timely information, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No individual or company should act upon such information without receiving appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of their particular situation. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of any articles. Thresholds, percentage rates and tax legislation may change in subsequent finance acts.

My wife and I really value the advice and support we’ve received over many years. Our key contact is Tim Cosway, whose friendly and calm manner is a real plus. He also involves team members who are equally committed. We particularly value that their approach is that no question is stupid – we always receive a clear and helpful explanation. We have full confidence in the team’s management of our finances and definitely recommend them.

Howard

We have consulted Holden and Partners for 10 years.  Having been in financial disarray because of poor advice from our previous financial advisor, we have Tim Cosway to thank for digging us out of a deep financial hole.  As a result of his painstaking tenacity pursuing a claim against our former financial advisor through the Financial Ombudsman Service, which resulted in substantial compensation, we can anticipate a comfortable retirement.  We continue to take Tim’s advice on all financial matters.  He is a pleasure to deal with, and we whole heartedly recommend Holden and Partners, and Tim in particular.

Mike & Jacque

I have been a customer of Holden & Partners since its inception. During this time, no matter what the state of the financial climate, I have always found that their advice has been balanced and fair. They have a good understanding of everyone’s individual circumstances and produced tailored strategies to match these needs and expectations.

Duncan B, NHS consultant

I’ve always received high quality, personable advice at a time of my convenience. My adviser has often travelled to my home in order to provide very personal service. The advice given is clear and unambiguous. The risks of different types of investment have been clearly discussed to allow me to make an appropriate decision on the nature of my investment portfolio. This has been of great importance when considering the available investment options for my forthcoming retirement. I have always considered that Holden & Partners is very client centred and they have my best interests at heart. I have been with Holden & Partners since 1996 and have recommended them to friends and colleagues on many occasions.

Michael, Surgeon

Holden & Partners manage our company pension scheme with a totally professional and dedicated approach. They have worked with us over a number of years, and are able to explain the potential ‘minefield’ that is pensions, to make it perfectly accessible for the staff.

Jeremy, Print Management Partner

On retirement after 40 years of salaried employment, I interviewed several financial advisers, amongst whom Mark Dodd of Holden & Partners was the nicest and seemingly the most understanding of my investment needs and priorities. Since then my wife and I have had regular (c.6-monthly) meetings with him in order to check and, when necessary, adjust the holdings in our portfolio. This has been very helpful and provided a comforting sense of confidence and security. I have recommended Holden & Partners to others and will certainly continue to do so.

Patrick, retired university professor

It’s easy to feel powerless in the face of global trends such as climate change and environmental destruction. But I feel I regain power as a consumer and a citizen by thinking about where I spend my money and to whom I entrust my savings. I chose Holden and Partners because they were recommended to me and because of their strong track record in ethical investments. It has proven to be a wise choice. Their advisors listened carefully to my needs and created an investment strategy and portfolio that has met and indeed continues to exceed my expectations. The culture of a company also matters to me, I have found their advisors to be well informed and financially shrewd but also easy to speak to and engage with. Many of us find it difficult to trust institutions and organisations these days, but I do trust Holden and Partners to make the right decisions on my behalf.
I would have no hesitation in recommending them to others.

Patrick, Advertising and Marketing Consultant

Read all our testimonials

Contact us

Whether it’s a question about your personal finances or how you can invest your wealth more ethically, we are here to help. Call us on 020 7812 1460, email info@holden-partners.co.uk or complete the form: